Is it moral for Muslims to deliver humanitarian aid to Ukraine’s refugees and people of other nationalities that Russia’s invasion has displaced into other border countries? Is it acceptable when the leaders of those host countries have brutally and resolutely barred Muslim refugees from their human right to life-saving hospitality for years only “because” they are Muslim, and even when many of the citizens of these nations — including some Ukrainians — have likewise shown contempt for Muslim refugees and non-European displaced peoples, openly declaring their enmity to Islam?
Some longtime and conscientious supporters of Muslim charities like the Zakat Foundation of America have raised this question to our staff and directors. They bitterly decry our March 3 call for Muslims and others to stand in the breach of the countries Ukraine borders — especially Poland, Hungary, and Romania — to provide relief to the hundreds of thousands of refugees and displaced streaming into them.
These objecting donors have condemned “any aid you provide to the displaced white, blue-eyed, and blonde-haired Ukrainians” as misguided humanitarianism at best, or simply “in vogue” opportunism, “jumping on” or “cashing in on the misery of these people.”
They say that they “cannot in good conscience support a racist and Islamophobic regime in Poland, which your organization will be supporting indirectly” with this aid, and that, as Muslims, they “along with many others feel the same way about this issue.”
This brings them to an incriminating moral judgment: “If you are going to be working with the Polish government on this, then you are also part of the racist and anti-Muslim problem in Europe.”
They deem any outside humanitarian effort from Muslims for Ukraine not only an ideological but also a chronological and geographical misappropriation of charity. “You could have done better to make people realize that Palestine and the Middle East including Syria (which shares the border and refugees in Turkey) is still a bigger and longer running issue than this recent one in Europe.”
Words mark the furthest extent of help Muslims can legitimately offer Ukraine, “to condemn the aggression perpetrated against them by Russia.” Beyond this lies moral transgression, they say. Hence, the charitable step Zakat Foundation of America has taken to help Ukrainian refugees in Poland, they contend, has carried us past the limits that Islam permits.
This, they say, has rightly earned us a “new and much more critical eye” from them for support of our humanitarian work. They “no longer have the respect … for your organization after your utter disregard of the Muslim sentiments on this matter.”
Now, our Prophet, on him be peace, has taught us that we Muslims are absolutely to uphold advice from one another — the giving and the taking of it — as a sacred religious duty we owe to one another. So we at Zakat Foundation of America quite sincerely want to thank our donors who offered their advice to us on Muslim relief for Ukraine.
Now, we want to return that religious favor of advice to these donors, and to all who would fulfill the sacred sadaqah imperative of the Quran and its Messenger, on him be peace, through the great blessing of the domestic and international humanitarian avenues Allah, in His mercy, has opened to us in our times.
We Muslims follow a path, not of personal emotion or partisan loyalty, but of divine Revelation. What Allah, Most High, and His Messenger, on him be peace, have given to us — in the Quran’s doubtless verses and the Prophet’s guiding way, on him be peace — we take.
Thus it is not ever befitting for a believing man or a believing woman, when Allah and His Messenger have decreed a matter, to have for themselves a contrary choice in their affairs. For whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has truly strayed into clear misguidance (Surat Al-Ahzab, 33:36).
This Revelation has specifically warned us to scrutinize the opinions and pronouncements that come to us, “so as not to afflict a people out of ignorance, and thereafter become regretful about what you have done” (Surat Al-Hujarat, 49:7).
Moreover, we are to be a people of deliberation and deliberateness when it comes to the actions we take because we Muslims remain the bearers of this decisive Heavenly guidance in the world, Revelation “recited” and “not recited.” The former is the Quran. The latter is the statements, actions, and approvals of the Prophet, on him be peace. This is his living Sunnah, which specifies the Quran for us. It is this that keeps our religion supple in our hearts and our practice of it dynamic through our lives and the ages. It is as if the Prophet, on him be peace, is still among us, leading the way.
So take note, for here Allah cautions us:
Were he [the Prophet] to follow the inclinations you express in most matters, you would, most surely, become overburdened with hardships (Surat Al-Hujarat, 49:7).
This means we cannot leave the ruling regarding the morality of Muslims providing humanitarian aid to Ukraine through a global Muslim charity (that has painstakingly put a human structure in place that can fulfill this for us with a click of our fingers) to impulse and whim. Rather, we should refer our feelings and biases back to Allah and His Messenger, on him be peace, for right guidance.